Saturday, 4 May 2024

Rogue One (Gareth Edwards, 2016)

The story of how the Rebel Alliance stole the Death Star plans, and brought about the wars in the stars.


Of the new Star Wars movies, this was the one I was the most excited about.


I had enjoyed The Force Awakens, but Rogue One felt new. It was going to expand the scope beyond the characters and the legacies we knew.


Plus it was working in a genre I liked - the men-on-a-mission war movie.


It is a format adopted in the first Star Wars movie, but this felt even closer to something like Guns of Navarone, with a small group pitched on an impossible mission.

When I first saw Rogue One in theatres, I was left vaguely disappointed.

The big issue I had was the characters.

The opening scene showing Galen’s (Mads Mikkelsen) kidnapping by the Empire is solid.

And then the movie turns into a blur, jumping between multiple worlds and characters. 

Occasionally the film sparks to life - Donnie Yen adds a welcome note of levity as the blind Chirrut Îmwe - but otherwise we are watching a collection of scenes shoving us toward the mission.

The final third of the film is the one chunk of Rogue One where it feels propulsive. I actually felt myself engaged, as the crew lands on Scarif and starts working through their plans for the obstacles. 

It’s not necessarily better, but the goal is clearer and the film does a good job of cross-cutting between the different elements of the operation.

The tropical location also makes the scenes stand out compared to the gloomy locales previously shown.

After watching a bunch of war movies last year, there is a familiarity to the men-on-a-mission hijinks that works, even if the people involved are not that well defined.

One wishes the movie had found a way to get to this mission sooner, since it is the first time it feels like something is at stake.

Darth Vader’s storming final act is great, but his earlier appearance - not to mention Grand Moff Tarkin’s various pop ups - feel unnecessary. They dilute Ben Mendelsohn’s Krennic as an antagonist. 

With almost a decade’s distance, the choice to include a digital recreation of Peter Cushing’s Grand Moff Tarkin is an anchor around this movie’s neck.

There is something disheartening about having a fine actor like Guy Henry performing an impersonation of another actor’s performance. It is stifling creativity and only makes the film feel more disconnected from the film it is supposedly preceding.

A fascinating break from the Skywalker saga, Rogue One is a flawed movie, but an interesting one. One hopes future Star Wars movies take the right lessons from it.

Related


If you enjoy something I wrote, and want to support my writing, here’s a link for tips!  

OUT NOW: Challengers (Luca Guadagnino, 2024)

Following a career-ending injury, Tashi Duncan (Zendaya) has put all her passion into the career of her husband, Art Donaldson (Mike Faist).


Now in an emotional and professional downturn, Art is on the way out of the sport - and his marriage.


In a last effort to boost his confidence, Tashi enters him into a Challengers tournament.


This puts the pair on a collision course with Art’s former friend and playing partner, and Tashi’s ex-boyfriend, Patrick Zweig (Josh O’Connor).



I need to watch more Luca Guadagnino movies. 


I have seen a couple of his more recent movies, but I think there is something missing that I cannot articulate.


This is the most I have enjoyed and been plugged into one of his movies.


Previously, I left his movies frustrated. With this movie, I left elated, energised.


I wanted to think over the characters and their dynamics.


Maybe it is the genre element, the spicy  high concept.


This is a movie about two men who love each other, but cannot consummate their attraction. They are both separated by and united by their attraction to Zendaya’s tennis star.


I do not like watching movies for the first time thinking about alternative castings but Zendaya jostles as Tashi.


She works in the flashbacks, particularly in the sequences where she first meets O’Connor and Faist.

 

But in the present sequences, something never clicked.


There is a moment towards the end of the movie where Josh O’Connor calls her a MILF and it was the first time I realised she was meant to be in her thirties.


That was when it really clicked. Zendaya is a striking presence, but the character is demanding a sense of history and contradiction that, try as she might, Zendaya cannot.


She is too but together, and too sardonic, to be a fully developed third of the triangle.


I had a bit of trouble with figuring out Zendaya and Faust’s relationship. She is so confident and controlled, while Faist is such a sad sack, I could not pull together where this bond came from.


Tashi ends up as a catalyst for the men, probably more than the filmmakers intended.


Josh O’Connor is good as the swaggering burnout. In terms of sexual charisma he is the most magnetic of the trio, with a knowing glint - he may play an obtuse meathead, but O’Connor brings a nihilistic self-awareness. He has been on this path so long, and cannot give it up.


Mike Faist was a highlight of West Side Story. Despite his baby face there is an inherent sadness to him that fits the character .


What is fascinating about the movie is that Tashi’s infatuation with the pair is as a pair.


She loves them as a complete being, a tennis Voltron whose combined personality can match her.


The flashback structure is a little overwrought. I found it slightly confusing, but I would be keen to see how it played in a rewatch.


Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross deliver a terrific score that manages to convey the sexual tension that the movie needs. 


I want to give the movie more thought. Consider this part one, for something more in-depth, at some point in the undetermined future.


If you enjoy something I wrote, and want to support my writing, here’s a link for tips!  

Friday, 3 May 2024

The Force Awakens (JJ Abrams, 2015)

Decades after the end of the Empire, a new force - the First Order - has arisen from its ashes.

A resistance movement has also arisen to fight it.

On a distant desert planet, young scavenger Rey (Daisy Ridley) stumbles upon a rebel droid BB8, and an ex-Storm Trooper, Fin (John Boyega), who are trying to get back to the resistance with news of the missing Jedi master, Luke Skywalker…



The Star Wars sequel trilogy has only been over for a few years, but it feels longer. Part of it is COVID, part of it is probably the memory-holing of the internet, and the complete absence of Star Wars from the big screen.

I have not watched any of the streaming shows, so I am probably more distant to these movies than the fanbase.

Now that this chapter of Star Wars is over, it is fascinating to look back on the sequel trilogy, and the anthology films which bracketed their release.

When The Force Awakens came out, I went to see it with friends. I was about 15 years past caring about the Wars, so I was coming in purely as a spectator.

At the time, I thought it was fun, but I found it hard to remember much from it. 

This is the first time I have watched it since it came out, and…

I still think it is a fun movie.

I was expecting to come away with something more concrete, but this movie is fun.

It is as light as a feather, with a story and scene of scene construction that do not work, but it is all carried away by its makers’ sense of pace and fun.

The film is also aided, nay amped up, by amazing casting.

One can knock JJ Abrams all they want but his eye for casting, and especially ensemble casting, is unimpeachable.

Ridley and Boyega in particular are instant movie stars.

Boyega had a little more cache from Attack the Block, but he is like a master juggler here, managing Fin’s rapid shift from tormented traitor to Rey’s goofy lovelorn friend.

On the page, the character might read as a bit of a jumble of different motivations, but Boyega makes the confection feel like a person - he is like a former cult member getting to embrace the world and his own mental freedom. 

The movie is in such a rush, and has to service so many characters that Fin’s journey gets lost a bit in the shuffle (a journey derailed by the sequels). 

In her first lead role, Daisy Ridley is instantly the centre of the movie. She leaves such a stamp on her first scenes, in which we see Rey living by herself

These scenes also feel like a riposte to the prequels. She lives by herself as an indentured servant, surviving on literal scraps.

The beginning of the movie has some great moments of character set up. And that’s kind of all the movie has.

The film always feels like it is just starting.

Almost as soon as we bring Finn and Rey together, then we go on a quest plot.

But unlike the Star Wars that precede it, The Force Awakens suffers from the same problem as JJ Abrams’ other projects.

He is in such a rush to gratify the audience - with action, with jokes, with big dramatic moments - that there is no sense of a story building.

It means the characters remain static, and the stakes are somewhat vague.

We get the destruction of a solar system and it picks none of the impact of the similar scene in A New Hope.

It is hard to not criticise the film for being a photocopy of 1977’s Star Wars. I remember Film Crit Hulk offering an incisive analysis of the ways in which this fails on a basic story-telling and character-building level.

While I did not go back and read that piece, I left the movie feeling unfulfilled

Ridley, Boyega and Oscar Isaac are great

They are magnetic to watch 

But who are they?

Rey is stuck on a planet as an indentured servant - forced to pay for daily food rations by hauling scraps for parts.

Finn has the most interesting set up of these new leads - a stormtrooper traumatized by war, and finally free to make his own choices. 

People can throw shots at the next movie all they want, but I can track where each character starts and ends up.

There is a definition to the characters that this movie only hints at. Here, it feels like they are being pushed along by plot.

It also feels like a bunch of Star Wars fans excited to get to hang out with Han Solo.

Harrison Ford is game, but his role feels abridged.

At the time, I remember being underwhelmed by the new antagonists, particularly Kylo Ren wearing a mask and speaking in a modulated voice.

It feels like the movie is cosplaying the Empire.

But that seems intentional -  and has ended up feeling like an echo of contemporary issues.

It is hard not to watch Domhnall Gleeson’s ranting speech and preening and think of the puffed up machismo of the online manosphere, or the gravy seals showing up at protests with M16s and body armour.

If Rey, Fin and Poe are rebel fans, the First Order are Empire fanboys.

This is looking ahead to future movies, but it makes sense that a group of Empire fans would fall under the sway of a creepy old force user like Snock. It also goes along with the previous trilogies, and the way in which the narrative and characters echo each other.

Flawed though it is, it is hard not to have fun with The Force Awakens.

But there is a fundamental conservatism to the film’s story choices that is frustrating.

I have not watched the prequels since they came out, and I was not keen to revisit them. But even while they are setting the scene, the filmmakers are trying to chart new territory.

The Force Awakens is a cinematic reaction to those movies. Aside from a great cast and some intriguing characters, it is obsessed with looking backwards. 

It is an attitude that would continue to plague the sequels era.

If you enjoy something I wrote, and want to support my writing, here’s a link for tips!  

Tuesday, 30 April 2024

James Bond 007 - The Duel & Dalton’s exit

In this season of The James Bond Cocktail Hour podcast, we are covering the six year gap between Licence to Kill and GoldenEye, covering everything James Bond-related, from books to comics to video games, to non-Bond properties which tried to fill the gap.


Our heroes check out Timothy Dalton's last 'appearance' in Bond-related media, and discuss his exit from Bond in 1994.

Check out the episode at the link below:










The Harry Palmer Trilogy


















If you enjoy something I wrote, and want to support my writing, here’s a link for tips!  

Monday, 29 April 2024

OUT NOW: The Fall Guy (David Leitch, 2024)

Following a career-ending injury, Stuntman Colt Seavers (Ryan Gosling) is parachuted back into action when the star who used to double, Tom Ryder (Aaron Taylor-Johnson), goes missing.


Enlisted as a stuntman/investigator by producer Gail (Hannah Waddingham), Colt is back in the viewfinder of director and former flame Jody (Emily Blunt).


Can Colt save the day? 





This might be the best David Leitch movie, and I still left it feeling nothing.


You can tell he is passionate about the subject.


But it is still a Leitch joint.


Directing is about making choices. 


It is a measure of taste, refracted through all the variables and structures of money, time, star ego and studio dictates.


This is along way of saying The Fall Guy suffers from the same problems as his previous movies: It is still too long, packed with unoriginal needle drops and too many extended comedic beats.


Leitch’s instincts are the most solid when he is constructing stunts, but he never figures out how to differentiate between the reel and real parts of his movie.


One of the big issues is that there is no differentiation between movie stunts and the real danger our hero is.


All the set pieces are constructed using the same cinematic language. There is no sense from the filmmakers that Colt is in danger.


It still feels like the movie is operating by the same logic as the action movie they are making. There is no contrast and therefore no irony (or stakes) to Sever’s predicament.


The movie benefits enormously from Gosling and Blunt. Their chemistry is fine, and they wring what pathos they can from the script.


Sadly, like other Leitch movies, The Fall Guy feels like it should be better than it is.


Related


Atomic Blonde


Deadpool 2


Hobbs & Shaw


Bullet Train


If you enjoy something I wrote, and want to support my writing, here’s a link for tips!